The source for all Tourism, Hotel and Real Estate news in Phuket.

RED SHIRTS Reports of My Death

Insider Story Locations

Find our most recent stories tagged by their locations. Click here for more story locations.

Posted: 17 Mar 2010 | 10:00 am

One of history's great lines which is often misquoted is Samuel Clemens (Mark Twain) line "reports of my death have been exaggerated." As it turned out the quotation was an exaggeration as the true story was a case of transmogrified news about Clemens relative James Ross Clemens. In fact the factual line is "the report of my death was an exaggeration.

Given the current media frenzy arising from the 'Red March' in Bangkok and spilling of blood on the streets, one could say the current perceived state of Thailand's public safety, politics and business is much an exaggeration. Viewing the world's dangers one of those favorite statistics by marine lovers around the globe is that 150 people died in a year from falling coconuts, which is 15 times the fatality rate of shark attacks. Taking a research spin on that one it appears again another case of exaggeration as there is little hard evidence to support this number.

It does present an interesting case though 'do coconut trees or shark attacks pose more of a threat to travelers then visiting Thailand?'

To date there have been no attributed deaths from the demonstrations. While estimates vary, most reports consistently number red shirt anti government demonstrators at less than 100,000. This in a country with an estimated population of 63 million people. It's a well known fact that the majority of this 'rent a crowd' supporters are merely indigent workers who fall below the minimum wage and are bused in, and paid a daily wage for wearing a red shirt and holding up those iconical plastic hand clappers.

While Thailand continues to make front page news the world around, many of the stories are simply journalists filing pieces aimed to sensationalize the mundane and perhaps ensure they can recoup their expenses from an extended holiday in the Land of Smiles. Media these days is a bit like American Idol, everyone looking for the next big thing. Perhaps this growing legion of 'war groupies' need to revisit the basic tenets of journalistic integrity.

Viewing the continually shrinking number of this lost tribe of pro-Thaksin supporters roaming the streets of Thailand is starting to take on nearly comical proportions. While the Paris Hilton of politicians Thaksin Shinawatra grasps at straws in one last attempt to return to power, the truth remains that the voice of Thai Democracy spoke loud and clear when it handed down the Supreme Court verdict on corruption and seizure of ill gained assets. That day in truth the tribe of the majority has spoken.

For Thailand's silent majority the international media has somehow forgotten to give them a voice and the truth remains that the silence is a deafening roar.

Travelers looking to visit the country or Phuket need to understand it's business as usual. There is far more political opposition say to US President Barak Obama's healthcare plan then there are red shirts. Given American's propensity to go postal and the availability of guns, it could be said travel here remains far safer then to many other places aboard.

Phuket is continuing to have its best high season in memory. The sun is out, the ocean is calm and there is not a sign of any unrest. As to those who would trumpet the Kingdom's demise, please note it's not we've been away. We've been here the entire time - Maybe not grabbing the headlines, but certainly enjoying the silence in the sun.

DO YOU LIKE THIS?
 
GOOD ARTICLE BILL, BUT I DONT AGREE WITH THE LAST PARAGRAPH....

...ALL IS NOT GOOD HERE IN PHUKET.

YOU PAINT A ROSY PICTURE...BUT PLEASE LOOK AT THE BIG PICTURE....
 
J D, 18 Mar 2010 | 1:07 pm
 
..."well known fact that the majority of this ‘rent a crowd' supporters are merely indigent workers who fall below the minimum wage..."

Fact according to whom? The yellow-hued press? I'm not a big fan of blood-spilling demos either, but I don't think we can so easily dismiss this movement as completely a 'rent a crowd' of poor dumb farmers. I think they have some legitimate concerns beyond Thaksin's petty battles with the generals.

The Nation (surprisingly!) had this to say about it yesterday:

***

Still, the massive presence of the red clad rural poor is a clear sign that mainstream politics has failed to meet the expectations of villagers.

Political parties and existing political mechanisms are undeniably dominated by the upper crust of society, with the political pie being shared by the middle class and urban workers, while the rural poor are left feeling hungry and cheated. Therefore, they can't help but believe that prosperity is only shared among a select few.

Many foot soldiers took turns at speaking on the main red-shirt rally stage at Phan Fah Bridge. They were nobodies who sounded uncouth and sometimes incoherent. Still they were speaking from the heart about the same thing - injustice.

It is a gross misjudgement to assume that the majority of the rural red shirts have fallen prey to the anti-government propaganda machine to rally for the individual interests of ex-premier Thaksin Shinawatra.

Unfortunately, Thaksin and his cohorts are exploiting the growing political consciousness in rural Thailand for personal gain...


Bill Barnett responds:
Thanks for the note and without a doubt the gap between rich and poor in this country is growing, as it is in every other country on earth. This sites commentary is aimed at the damages to tourism and the media frenzy the world over, which is sensatonalized. The images portrayed show a country in chaos, and tend to discourge many to travel.

What is a shame is that a just cause has been hijacked and politicized by Thaksin. Generalizations are never fair and the intentions here view what has been largely a funded demonstration to return the former Prime Minister to power have created severe issues for Phuket and Thailand in general.

We will leave the politics of the poor which I fully agree are a growing social power to the far wiser then this blog, but at the same time our message from the article remains for travelers looking to come to Phuket, its all fine here. While we may have issues with tuk tuks, jet skis, motorcylce accidents and drownings, tell me any tourist destination that does not have its own issues. We'd like to balance the images that those abroad see with demonstrators throwing blood on the steets in Bangkok with the reality of a terrific destination in Phuket that travelers need not worry to visit.

Thank your for your thoughtful comments and point of view.
 
Lana, 17 Mar 2010 | 9:18 pm
 
HI BILL, WHATS HAPPENED TO MY COMMENT HAVE YOU FORGOT TO PRINT IT?


Bill Barnett responds:
Must have missed it as we have printed all we received, please resend.
 
J D, 17 Mar 2010 | 5:51 pm
 
Only a columnist with property connections would write the ''tenants'' of basic journalism instead of the tenets. I do have to ask, though, what genuine grounds you have for saying it's the ''best high season in memory.'' Have you been in a tuk-tuk lately?
Bill Barnett responds:
Thanks for the comments and indeed the heads up on the typo. Best high season would refer to the occupancy and average room rate of internationally managed hotels on the island in a comparison of figures for 2007, 2008 and 2009. No guesswork here so its a qualfied statement as are tourism numbers which saw the the fourth quarter of 2009 start of high season return to 2007 figures. Again based on AoT arrvial data and qualified. As for tuk tuks? While they continue to be a source of complaints and no one can deny an issue as are jet skis, drownings and motorcycle deaths. By the numbers when we say recent memory the 2-3 year historically its been a good high season.

Thanks for spotting the typo, we property guys are indeed prone to typing errors at even the best of times.
 
Alan, 17 Mar 2010 | 4:35 pm
 
Whatever the rights or wrongs of The Reds, Thailand remains a great place to live in or visit. However, the sloshing around of that blood at the gates of Mouse House was pretty sickening, not to mention unhealthy. Was it checked for HIV, I wonder ?


 
Peter N, 17 Mar 2010 | 1:26 pm

Post a Comment

Your comments will appear after approval. Please stay relevant to this blog entry.

 
 
 
 
 

The Green Report

A column featuring environmental issues and conservation around the island. Click here for more Green Reports check out the latest story from the leading experts:

TV Show Features Phuket Solar Villa

A recent Channel News Asia television segment Boomtown Asia checked into the island's environmental, and sustainable tourism sectors.

Resorts Loving Evening Breeze Natural Air System

The innovative Evening Breeze environmental cooling system is gaining global attention in the resort markets and villas.

 
THAI HOTEL SHARE PRICES
Name Current Change

CENTEL 37.75 + 0.50 %

DTC 60.25 0.00 %

ERW 5.25 + 0.10 %

GRAND 1.62 + 0.02 %

LRH 42.75 - 0.25 %

MANRIN 27.00 - 1.00 %

MINT 27.00 - 1.00 %

ROH 22.00 + 0.20 %

SHANG 58.00 0.00 %

*Disclaimer.

 
VIDEO FEATURES

Richard Branson/Airasia - Coffee Tea or Me

More Videos...

 
 
 

Stay Connected

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • RSS
  • 1Report
  • Follow Us on Pinterest
 
CURRENCY CONVERTER
 

*Disclaimer.

 

Insider Contact

Please complete all fields.